amntrans AMNESTY HEARINGS 1999-02-02 NELSPRUIT 2 RAPHEAL SENZAGAKHONA SITHOMO GRENADE ATTACK ON BUS https://sabctrc.saha.org.za/hearing.php?id=53152&t=&tab=hearings https://sabctrc.saha.org.za/originals/amntrans/1999/99020105_nel_990202ne.htm CHAIRPERSON Thank you very much, Mr Claassen. Mr Claassen the next person I think we will proceed to hear is Mr Sithomo, who is the second applicant in this application and from the reading of his application, I must say we take the view that he's application should be fairly short. I don't know whether Mr Sithole agrees with the way we understand the issues dealt in Mr Sithomo's application which really curtail the proceedings. In that case, because we seem to be having a common understanding, Ms Thabete also has the same view, we would request Correctional Services to accommodate us. We are aware that they are supposed to go back at 4 o'clock. We feel that this matter is capable of being disposed of within an hour. The time now is twenty five to four. I think the matter might be finalised before half past four, and we would request their indulgence in that regard. ...(end of tape) such a reasonable request would do great injustice to the victims who are coming from Heidelberg, who will have to be accommodated at great expense to the Commission on a matter which could have been disposed of in about 20 minutes time. Can I take it that our request to Correctional Services is acceded to? Thank you very much. We then proceed to hear the application of Mr Rapheal Senzagakhona Sithomo. CHAIRPERSON Are you speaking in Zulu? Can you understand me? RAPHEAL SENZAGAKHONA SITHOMO (sworn states) CHAIRPERSON Mr Claassen, you may proceed. EXAMINATION BY MR CLAASSEN Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr Sithomo, could you state your full names for the record? MR SITHOMO Rapheal Senzagakhonea Sithomo. MR CLAASSEN Mr Sithomo, is it true that you filled out an application form and also submitted an affidavit, a statement which was made on the application form concerning the incident for which you are currently serving a jail sentence, and which is also the reason why you are applying for amnesty today? MR SITHOMO That's correct. MR CLAASSEN Mr Sithomo, can you very briefly in your own words tell the Committee exactly what happened and what your involvement was. MR SITHOMO I wasn't at work on that day. The reason I'm in this problem is because of the political situation. I wasn't there when this incident occurred. I took leave from the 11th, I went home. After that I heard on the radio news about the incident which occurred at Ratanda. From what I heard I didn't have a problem or I didn't associate myself with the incident. MR LAX Sorry, did he say he did or he didn't associate himself, Mr Claassen? I just wasn't clear, the interpretation wasn't very clear. Please if you can just either repeat the answer or the interpretation or both. MR SITHOMO I didn't have anything to do with the incident because I was absent, I wasn't there. This is the truth. MR CLAASSEN Mr Sithomo, you just stated that you heard what had happened over the radio, had you any prior knowledge of any such planning? MR SITHOMO You mean before the incident? MR CLAASSEN That's correct. MR SITHOMO No, I didn't have any prior knowledge about this, no-one told me anything that people were going to attack people in the bus. MR CLAASSEN And you had no personal involvement in perpetrating this act? MR SITHOMO The truth is I didn't have any knowledge about this incident. MR CLAASSEN Thank you, Madam Chair, I have no further questions. NO FURTHER QUESTIONS BY MR CLAASSEN CHAIRPERSON Thank you very much. Before we proceed to Mr Sithole, may I just on a question of clarity find out when you left for your leave, can you remember? Was it in September, early September or was it in August? MR SITHOMO It was on the 11th of September. CHAIRPERSON And where were you on the 28th of September? We know you were on leave but in which place? MR SITHOMO Escort, at Mthabomhlope in Escort. CHAIRPERSON Thank you very much. Mr Sithole, do you have any questions to put to Mr Sithomo in view of his brief evidence before us? CROSS-EXAMINATION BY MR SITHOLE As the Chair pleases. There is just one question, Madam Chair, and it relates to the earlier question I wanted to ask Mr Hadebe on page 17 of the paginated documents. I see on paragraph 9(a)IV you allege that Thokozani Biela, Kujeza Nxango, Mpakisani Choncho, Thandogwake Ndlovu and Zaccarehia Mhlongo committed the offence, how did you come to know about the fact that they committed the offence? MR SITHOMO This is a mistake that I mentioned these people. These are the people that I knew but I didn't say these were the people who perpetrated this crime. MR SITHOLE I have no further questions, Madam Chair. NO FURTHER QUESTIONS BY MR SITHOLE CHAIRPERSON Thank you, Mr Sithole. Ms Thabete, do you have any questions to put to Mr Sithomo? MS THABETE No questions, Madam Chair. CHAIRPERSON Thank you. Mr Lax? MR LAX No questions, Chairperson. CHAIRPERSON Ms Bosman? ADV BOSMAN No questions, thank you Chairperson. CHAIRPERSON There is no reason to come back to you Mr Claassen for any re-exam and I shall not do so. Are you closing your case, Mr Claassen? MR CLAASSEN That would be my case, Madam Chairperson, concerning Mr Sithomo that is. CHAIRPERSON Yes. MR CLAASSEN That is correct. CHAIRPERSON Thank you. But in respect of the two applications, do you propose to call any further witnesses in support of Mr Hadebe's application for instance? MR CLAASSEN Not on the evidence that we gave today, Madam Chair. CHAIRPERSON Do you propose to call any witnesses at all in respect of any issue? MR CLAASSEN Madam Chair, as far as witnesses are concerned, no. CHAIRPERSON Thank you. MR CLAASSEN There's just the amendment of the application as previously discussed. CHAIRPERSON Yes. So you have therefore closed your case? MR CLAASSEN I have, I have. WITNESS EXCUSED CHAIRPERSON Mr Sithole, you had given an indication that you intended to call one witness. MR SITHOLE Yes, Madam Chair. CHAIRPERSON We will proceed you that opportunity to do so. MR SITHOLE Thanks Madam Chair. Johanna Msibi. CHAIRPERSON Is she going to testify? MR SITHOLE Yes, Madam Chair. CHAIRPERSON Does she speak Zulu? What language does she prefer to use? MR SITHOLE Zulu, Madam Chair. CHAIRPERSON Sotho? MR SITHOLE Zulu, Madam Chair. CHAIRPERSON You may stand to take the oath. Your full names are Johanna Msibi? JOHANNA MSIBI (sworn states) CHAIRPERSON You can sit down. You may proceed, Mr Sithole. EXAMINATION BY MR SITHOLE Thanks, Madam Chair. Johanna, is it correct that on the 28th of September 1992 you were employed at Escort Factory in Heidelberg? MS MSIBI That's correct. MR SITHOLE And is it correct that on that day you knocked off and boarded a bus which was taking you home? MS MSIBI Yes, that's correct. MR SITHOLE Can you briefly explain to this Committee what happened when you were about to reach the hostel in Ratanda? MS MSIBI "The name of that street next to the hostel is Prode(?). When the bus arrived next to the hostel or in front of the hostel there were four men standing there and there was a fire. When the bus approached there I saw Hadebe taking an object and throwing it in the bus. I didn't know that that thing was a bomb, I thought it was a stone. I only realised that it was a handgrenade after it exploded on my foot." MR SITHOLE And what injuries did you sustain in that incident? MS MSIBI My right foot and my hip, my right hip. MR SITHOLE And according to you, do you know of any reason why you were attacked? MS MSIBI I didn't know that we were going to be attacked but when the firms started we were given two choices to join unions and the white guy agreed that we should join one union. We didn't want to join Uwusa, we decided to join Fawu. MR SITHOLE And after that, what happened, can you tell the Committee what happened? MS MSIBI After that we decided to go on strike and the Uwusa members decided to continue working. When we were supposed to go back to work we couldn't because there were people who were chasing us away, not the people who were working with us. We didn't know those people. Those people were new people, new members in that firm. Later we agreed that we should go back to work. I was surprised when we were attacked. MR SITHOLE Alright. Can you explain to this Committee as to what happened at work in the morning of the 28th of September? MS MSIBI When we arrived at work, at 10 o'clock after teatime, Mr Hadebe came and he was crying. He didn't say anything to me but he was crying and I saw him leaving and I saw him in the evening when he was throwing an object in the bus. MR SITHOLE And can you tell this Committee what is your feeling towards the applicant, Mzobona? MS MSIBI I wouldn't like to see him getting amnesty because what he is saying here is not the truth. Everything he's said here is not true. Even in Court he lied, even here he's lying today. MR SITHOLE I have no further questions, Madam Chair. NO FURTHER QUESTIONS BY MR SITHOLE CHAIRPERSON Thank you, Mr Sithole. Mr Claassen, do you have any questions to put to Ms Msibi? MR CLAASSEN Madam Chair, I've just a few questions I would like to put to her. CHAIRPERSON Proceed to do so. CROSS-EXAMINATION BY MR CLAASSEN Thank you, Madam Chair. Ms Msibi, at the time of this particular incident you've just testified that you were a member of Fawu, did you also belong to any other political organisation? INTERPRETER The speaker's mike is not on. CHAIRPERSON Mr Sithole, will you assist us in ensuring that her speaker is on to be able to transcribe her evidence all the time. Right now her speaker is off. MS MSIBI I was just a Fawu member, not a member of any political organisation. MR CLAASSEN Ms Msibi, is it not true that for the most part Fawu members were also affiliated and members of the ANC? CHAIRPERSON Are you saying they were always or are you saying they were perceived? There is a world of difference between those two. MR CLAASSEN Madam Chair, my apologies, I would like to rephrase it. Ms Msibi, is it true that most members of Fawu were also members of the ANC? CHAIRPERSON Is it not better, Mr Claassen, to put it as I think you should put it, that members of Fawu were perceived to be members of the ANC? MR CLAASSEN As the Chair pleases. MS MSIBI Yes, some people used to view Fawu members as ANC members, but when I affiliated with Fawu it was strictly Fawu, not ANC. I was never affiliated with ANC. MR CLAASSEN Ms Msibi, on this particular afternoon when you went home with this ill-fated bus, the people aboard the bus, were they exclusively Fawu members? MS MSIBI They were strictly Fawu members in the bus. MR CLAASSEN Only Fawu? MS MSIBI Yes, only Fawu. Only union members could board that bus and strictly Fawu union. MR CLAASSEN And was this a known practice, that only Fawu members used the buses? MS MSIBI Yes, it was a known factor. MR CLAASSEN Ms Msibi, you testified that you saw Mr Hadebe throw something at the bus. MS MSIBI Yes, I saw him. MR CLAASSEN It is my instructions that he, and I put it to you that he indeed did not throw anything towards this bus. MS MSIBI I deny that because I saw him personally. I saw him. There was a fence next to the hostel and they've already demolished the fence and there was a fire there and when the bus approached that fire, I saw him picking an object next to the fire and I am quite certain that I saw him and I saw him throwing that object into the bus. MR CLAASSEN Ms Msibi, just going back to the circumstances at your workplace before this incident. MS MSIBI Do you want me to explain the situation or ... MR LAX That is correct. The question is, were there often fights between Fawu and Uwusa? MS MSIBI We were not fighting with them. We used to talk to the white men. We were the majority, we Fawu members, and Uwusa were the few. MR CLAASSEN And was there never any incident between the two parties? MS MSIBI Yes, after the strike we were attacked. When we came to work, as we were changing, putting on our working clothes, one man came and told us not to do so because people were going to attack us. Therefore, we didn't work, we left and they were the only ones who were working. CHAIRPERSON When you say after the strike we were attacked, can you explain to us when was this strike and on what day did you come back from the strike and the day when they tried to attack you? MS MSIBI When we went on strike, I don't remember exactly when was it, but I remember that it was on the 22nd of July. We went on strike on the 22nd of July. CHAIRPERSON How long did you stay on this strike? MS MSIBI We stayed about a month or two, I'm not sure. This was in July. We went on strike in July and then we came back to work after two or three months. I'm not sure when. CHAIRPERSON When you were injured, how long had you been at work? MS MSIBI I can't say exactly because I don't remember whether we returned to work in August or September. CHAIRPERSON Thank you. If there is someone amongst the victims, Mr Sithole, who could just assist us on this small piece of information, we would appreciate it. MR SITHOLE We have someone, Madam Chair. Madam Chair, he says in September. He's not even clear when it was. CHAIRPERSON I think that's sufficient. The strike occurred around the 22nd of July and the workers returned to work in or about September. Thank you. MR CLAASSEN Ms Msibi, what sort of problems were there at work after your return? MS MSIBI You mean when we returned from the strike? MR CLAASSEN Yes. MS MSIBI The only problems we found were that they used to chase us away and then after that was resolved we didn't have much problems. I guess maybe I was ignorant because I couldn't see any problems at work. MR CLAASSEN How was this problem solved? CHAIRPERSON Which problem? MR CLAASSEN Madam Chair, she just testified that after it was solved ...(intervention) CHAIRPERSON The labour. Do you mean the strike? Are you referring to the strike as a labour dispute? MR CLAASSEN Madam Chair, if I understood the witness correctly, unless I misunderstood I think she said that problems occurred after their return. I'm under the impression that the strike was already over by then and I don't know what other problem she might have been referring to or how this was resolved. MS MSIBI Police were the ones who resolved this. Police came and they resolved this and the organiser as well was involved and the manager. He is the one who told these people who were trying to chase us away that they mustn't do that anymore. CHAIRPERSON I'm on the same page. I wasn't on the same page with you, Mr Claassen. MR CLAASSEN Thank you, Madam Chair. Ms Msibi, just to get back to this point, you said that the police resolved the issue, how did they resolve this issue? MS MSIBI They called the police and they were told that we were supposed to come back to work and other people were chasing us away and the policemen were told that they should come because there were people who were harassing us. Then the manager told the police as well that he was going to talk to these people and tell them not to harass us. MR CLAASSEN Ms Msibi, can you remember when this problem was resolved, how long was this before the incident of the attack on the bus? MS MSIBI I would say if we went to work in September, after three weeks the bus was attacked. MR CLAASSEN Thank you, Madam Chair, I have no further questions of this witness. NO FURTHER QUESTIONS BY MR CLAASSEN CHAIRPERSON Thank you, Mr Claassen. Ms Thabete, do you have any questions to put to Ms Msibi? MS THABETE Yes, Madam Chair. CHAIRPERSON Please proceed to do so. CROSS-EXAMINATION BY MS THABETE Thank you. I just need clarification, are you Miss Msibi or Mrs Msibi? CHAIRPERSON She's Miss. MS MSIBI Ms Msibi, would it be correct or would it be incorrect for me to say that at the workplace after the strike there was a conflict between people who were perceived to be IFP and people who were perceived to be ANC? MS MSIBI Yes, that's correct. MS THABETE Can you elaborate on your answer? Is it correct for me to say so? MS MSIBI Yes, that's correct. MS THABETE Is it also true that Fawu members used buses whilst Uwusa members used taxis? MS MSIBI That's correct. MS THABETE On the day in question, whereabouts were you seated in the bus? MS MSIBI I was standing at the back, not the real back seat but at the back of the bus. I was standing there. MS THABETE Were you seated or were you standing? MS MSIBI ...(no audible reply) When the bus went through you say you saw Mzobona Hadebe, was he the only there or did you see any other person or other people there? CHAIRPERSON She saw four. Ms Thabete, the evidence was that there were four persons. Her evidence was that there were four persons, including Hadebe. That's her evidence. MS THABETE Do you know anybody else besides Mr Hadebe who was there? MS MSIBI I saw Mr Hadebe and I saw Sandi even though I didn't see him throwing something but I saw Mr Hadebe throwing something and also I saw Sandi. CHAIRPERSON Who is Sandi, Ms Msibi, do you know the surname of Sandi? MS MSIBI He's the one sitting here in front of the Committee. CHAIRPERSON Oh, Mr Sithomo? MS MSIBI Yes, Mr Sithomo. CHAIRPERSON Was he standing there next to Hadebe? MS MSIBI Yes, he was. CHAIRPERSON You also said that there were four people, is it true if ones says the two of the four people is Mr Sithomo and Mr Hadebe? MS MSIBI Yes, it's true. MS THABETE I assume that you know, or it's been the evidence that you know Mr Hadebe from work, where do you know Mr Sithomo from? MS MSIBI Yes, I used to see him at work and also in the township. MS THABETE Thank you, no further questions, Madam Chair. NO FURTHER QUESTIONS BY MS THABETE CHAIRPERSON Ms Msibi, you say you know Mr Sithomo from the location and from work? INTERPRETER The speaker's mike is not on. MS MSIBI ...(no English translation) CHAIRPERSON How long have you been employed at the factory? MS MSIBI I know him because I used to see him in the township. CHAIRPERSON Now this - for how long had you been in the employ of the factory when this incident occurred? MS MSIBI 13 years. CHAIRPERSON In what department were you employed? MS MSIBI Kitchen department which was called Department Number One. CHAIRPERSON And where did you usually see both Mr Sithomo and Mr Hadebe at work, was it during your tea break, lunch hour or was there an occasion when ...(intervention) MS MSIBI I would see him during lunchtime and even inside the firm as we were walking from area to the other, and also outside the firm and the township as well. I know them. CHAIRPERSON For how long did you know Mr Hadebe as a colleague working at the same factory where you worked? MS MSIBI I joined the firm in 1981. I don't know if he joined before me or after me but when I joined the firm as time went on I realised that he was one of my colleagues, but I cannot tell whether he came before me or after me. CHAIRPERSON The incident occurred in September of 1992, would you say you had known Mr Hadebe for a few months prior to that incident? Would you say you had known him for a year or for more than a year? Can you just give us an approximation. MS MSIBI For years. I can say maybe 13 years because I was in that firm for 13 years and I think I've known him since I've joined the firm. CHAIRPERSON And Mr Sithomo, for how long had you known him as a colleague working at Escort Bacon Factory? MS MSIBI Him as well I think I've known for quite a while, I think years. I don't know whether he came before me or after me but I've known him for years as well. CHAIRPERSON Would it also be more than three years? MS MSIBI Yes, I think it's far more than three years. CHAIRPERSON If you say it's far much more, approximately what would you estimate the period? MS MSIBI I estimate it like 13 years because I'm not sure whether he came before me or after me, but I think it was 13 years. CHAIRPERSON Now apart from the working environment were you would interact, how would you be able to interact with either of them in the township? The evidence that was led before us was that, at least by Mr Hadebe, there was little interaction ...(intervention) MS MSIBI We used to meet each other in the township. They used to stay or live with the people who were staying in the township. There wasn't a common except work where I can meet them, but we used to meet in the streets in the township. CHAIRPERSON Did you know that Mr Hadebe stayed at the hostel, Ratanda Hostel? MS MSIBI Yes, I knew that. CHAIRPERSON Were the hostel dwellers well accepted by the inhabitants of Ratanda Location? MS MSIBI Before the violence the hostel dwellers used to go to the townships. CHAIRPERSON And when can you approximate the conflict to have commenced between the hostel dwellers and the inhabitants of the location? MS MSIBI I think it was on the 22nd of July, on the day when we went on strike. CHAIRPERSON That's when the conflict between the hostel dwellers and the community in Ratanda ...(intervention) MS MSIBI Yes, I would say so, I would say the conflict started on the day when we went on strike because before that the hostel dwellers used to visit the location but then when we went on strike that's when the conflict started, or the violence. CHAIRPERSON Are you suggesting that you know Mr Hadebe and Mr Sithomo so well that you can identify them probably even when they are not facing you? MS MSIBI Yes, that's what I'm suggesting. CHAIRPERSON And you couldn't have probably been incorrect in your testimony when you say you actually saw Mr Hadebe throwing something at the bus that you were in? MS MSIBI No, I'm not making a mistake, I'm telling the truth. CHAIRPERSON Thank you. Mr Lax, do you have any questions to put to Ms Msibi? MR LAX No questions Chair, you've covered everything. CHAIRPERSON Ms Bosman, do you have any questions to put to Ms Msibi? ADV BOSMAN Thank you, Chair, just one or two. Ms Msibi, did you know about the death of Mr Mgababa? MS MSIBI Yes, I heard about his death at work on that Monday, but I didn't hear about it in the township. I only came to find out about it at work on Monday morning. ADV BOSMAN Did you know who Mr Mgababa was? MS MSIBI Yes, I knew Mr Mgababa because he was also working with us. ADV BOSMAN Did you know his political affiliation? MS MSIBI Yes, I knew that he was an Uwusa members. ADV BOSMAN Then just one more question, I'm a little unclear on this. You made mention of a fire when the bus passed, what time of the day was it? MS MSIBI It was half past five and I hold my watch. It was half past five. ADV BOSMAN Can you possibly tell us why there was a fire, was it dark or ...? If you don't know ...(intervention) MS MSIBI I don't know why they had a fire there but there was a fire. ADV BOSMAN And was it dark or was it still fairly light that time? - I don't know the area. MS MSIBI No, there was light, there was no darkness, there was a clear light. ADV BOSMAN Thank you. CHAIRPERSON Thank you, Ms Bosman. I just want to get clarification on one very minor aspect. When you gave evidence you said that you saw Mr Hadebe at about 10 o'clock on the 28th of September, this is when this incident, the day of the occurrence of the incident, you saw him coming out of the company crying and you didn't know what he was crying about. Now you saw him crying, how did you know that he was crying? You saw tears coming out of his ...(intervention) MS MSIBI Yes, I saw his tears and he was leaving, going towards the gate. CHAIRPERSON Oh, I thought maybe there was a mistake in the translation or something. Ms Sithole, oh sorry, Mr Sithole. MR SITHOLE Thank you, Madam Chair, I think that's the evidence on the side of the victims. We are not going to call any further witnesses. WITNESS EXCUSED CHAIRPERSON Yes. Well we are greatly indebted to all of you for having made these proceedings to be as curtailed but also detailed as possible. And our gratitude to Correctional Services for having acceded to our request and true to our undertaking, indeed we have been able to finalise at least this portion of the evidence before four thirty. Where do we go from here, Mr Claassen, Mr Sithole and Ms Thabete. I'm not calling you lastly because you are a lady, because you are our Evidence Leader, I think the ball should really be in Mr Claassen's court. Insofar as the presentation or argument is concerned, do you want to address us today, which you can proceed to do and we don't need in that case the presence of the victims if Mr Sithole will be around. You can proceed to do so or you may elect to do so tomorrow morning. MR CLAASSEN Thank you for the opportunity, Madam Chair. If it will suite all the relevant parties I would prefer to address the Committee tomorrow morning. CHAIRPERSON Can we just arrange with you some of the issues that we would like you to apply your minds on when you prepare for your address. MR CLAASSEN Certainly, I would appreciate that. You will see that from the papers and on the evidence led by Mr Hadebe in particular, his testimony is basically that he only participated in the planning of the attack and that planning was on the 27th of September, but denies participation in the attack that led to him being convicted for the offences for which amnesty is being sought. We would like you to address us specifically on that issue, whether he can qualify for amnesty for the offences for which he's convicted, on the basis of his participation only to the extent of planning for the commission of those offences. You may wish also to apply your mind on the question of proportionality and obviously on any other issue that you would like to address us on but mainly and fundamentally we would appreciate if you could give us something, specifically with regard to the first issue. MR CLAASSEN I will do so, and I thank you for the opportunity, Madam Chair. CHAIRPERSON Mr Sithole, do you have any objection to the address being presented tomorrow morning without your clients being here? MR SITHOLE No, Madam Chair, I don't think it will have any effect whatsoever on my clients. CHAIRPERSON Yes, we would like to extend our appreciation for the efforts I think made by the victims in attending these hearings. We hope that on its own will go a great way in trying to heal the wounds that we know have been bleeding for quite some time. We'll now bring these proceedings to a close and we'll resume tomorrow at 9 o'clock. Thank you. COMMITTEE ADJOURNS