<?xml version="1.0" encoding="windows-1252"?>
<hearing xmlns="http://trc.saha.org.za/hearing/xml" schemaLocation="https://sabctrc.saha.org.za/export/hearingxml.xsd">
	<systype>hrvtrans</systype>
	<type>HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS, SUBMISSIONS QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS</type>
	<startdate>1997-05-14</startdate>
	<location></location>
	<day>3</day>
	<names>TEMBEGA GLADYS BATA</names>
							<url>https://sabctrc.saha.org.za/hearing.php?id=55493&amp;t=&amp;tab=hearings</url>
	<originalhtml>https://sabctrc.saha.org.za/originals/hrvtrans/kwtown/kwtbata.htm</originalhtml>
		<lines count="83">
		<line number="1">
			<speaker>CHAIRPERSON</speaker>
			<text>We request that Tembega Gladys Bata come forward please.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="2">
			<speaker>TEMBEGA GLADYS BATA:</speaker>
			<text>(sworn states)</text>
		</line>
		<line number="3">
			<speaker>CHAIRPERSON</speaker>
			<text>We request that Ntsikii Sandi lead you in evidence on behalf of the Commission.  Thank you Mr Chairperson.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="4">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Mrs Bata, I also welcome you.  You are going to talk about Lizo Desmond Bata, is that so ?.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="5">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>Yes.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="6">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>The late Mr Bata was your husband, is that so ?.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="7">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>Yes, Sir.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="8">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Could you tell us fully what happened to him.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="9">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text></text>
		</line>
		<line number="10">
			<speaker></speaker>
			<text></text>
		</line>
		<line number="11">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Were there people  Mrs Bata, who were arrested for this ?.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="12">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>No.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="13">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Before this happened, were there incidents at home like this ?.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="14">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>No.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="15">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Were there people perhaps from the Ciskeian Defence Force or Ciskeian Police Force who would come to your house looking for a particular person ?.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="16">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>The Ciskeian soldiers would come looking for Xembisi Bata but they would not go to home,  but to the other house.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="17">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Who was Xembisi Bata?.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="18">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>That is our Nephew.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="19">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Therefore its a member of the family ?.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="20">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>Yes.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="21">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>According to your statement you suspect the perpetrators, you have an idea.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="22">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>Yes, I do.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="23">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Would you tell us about these people?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="24">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>I suspect the Ciskeian soldiers.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="25">
			<speaker>MR  SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Do you have reason to suspect the Ciskeian soldiers ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="26">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>Yes, I do.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="27">
			<speaker>MR  SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Could you give us these reasons ?.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="28">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>First of all, when the bomb was exploding, this, when the bomb, after the bomb exploded the soldiers were there in the yard.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="29">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Did you get any treatment from the doctor ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="30">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>I used to go to the doctor in 1992 and 93.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="31">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Did you have children with Mr Bata ?.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="32">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>Yes.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="33">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>How old are the children ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="34">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>My eldest was born in 1973, the second born 1976 and the, and, and my third 1977, my last one 1985.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="35">
			<speaker>MR   SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Are they all at school ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="36">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>Yes, they are.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="37">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Could you tell us how the children were affected by this incident.  Surely they were affected cause they were quite young when the father passed away.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="38">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>I did not notice anything.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="39">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>How do they feel about the way their father died ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="40">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>They were very hurt.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="41">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>What was your father doing, your husband doing ?.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="42">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>He was a taxi man.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="43">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>How long had he been a taxi man ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="44">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>Quite a while.  More than 11 years.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="45">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Why do you think that the Ciskeian Defence Force killed Lizo Desmond Bata ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="46">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>I think that it was a mistaken, they were looking for Xembisi.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="47">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Are these house, are their houses next to each other ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="48">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>Yes.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="49">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Where were you staying at the time ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="50">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>At Xue Xue.  Xue Xue township.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="51">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Next to Bisho ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="52">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>Yes.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="53">
			<speaker>MR. SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Is that all the evidence that you have, Mrs Bata ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="54">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>Yes.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="55">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Do you have a request in connection with this incident ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="56">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>I would like to know the perpetrators.  Who they are.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="57">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>You have a request according to your statement, about your children.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="58">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>If I could be helped with the children, so that they can be educated.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="59">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Was Mr Bata politically active.  Did he belong to any political organization ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="60">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>No, he did not belong to any political organization.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="61">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text></text>
		</line>
		<line number="62">
			<speaker>CHAIRPERSON</speaker>
			<text>Calls June Crichton.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="63">
			<speaker>MRS CRICHTON</speaker>
			<text>Can you hear me, Mrs Bata ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="64">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>Yes, I can hear you.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="65">
			<speaker>MRS CRICHTON</speaker>
			<text>Just one question.    Did  you  get  any  legal advice about this at all,</text>
		</line>
		<line number="66">
			<speaker></speaker>
			<text>make a statement to the police or approach an attorney ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="67">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>I gave a statement to the police.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="68">
			<speaker>MRS CRICHTON</speaker>
			<text>Did anything happen as a result of that ?.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="69">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>There was a investigation, but no results came of it.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="70">
			<speaker>MRS CRICHTON</speaker>
			<text>Your husband was a member, well not a member, but he was a taxi driver for 11 years.  He belonged to Bata.  Was there any assistance from them when this happened ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="71">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>We were not helped at all.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="72">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Mrs Bata I just need clarity.  What was the taxi association that your husband was a member of ?</text>
		</line>
		<line number="73">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>It was Begita.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="74">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>At the time of  the incident, Mrs Bata, was there perhaps unrest with, especially the taxi men.  Were they fighting at the time ?.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="75">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>No.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="76">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>You said you reported this at the police.  Who as a policeman was leading the investigation ?.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="77">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>I do not know, but it was at Zwelitsha police station.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="78">
			<speaker>MR SANDI</speaker>
			<text>Did the police come to you to take a statement ?.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="79">
			<speaker>MRS BATA</speaker>
			<text>Yes, they did.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="80">
			<speaker>CHAIRPERSON</speaker>
			<text>Are there any questions ?.</text>
		</line>
		<line number="81">
			<speaker></speaker>
			<text></text>
		</line>
		<line number="82">
			<speaker></speaker>
			<text></text>
		</line>
		<line number="83">
			<speaker></speaker>
			<text></text>
		</line>
	</lines>
</hearing>